Valentine’s Day has demarcated the relationship paths for many people over the years. On this day some relationships move forward, some backwards, and some end altogether.
In the 1920’s the city of Chicago had simultaneous relationships with multiple crime bosses, and 96 years ago today Al Capone put an end to that and made his relationship with Chicago exclusive.
Although never convicted of the crime, Al is generally considered to be responsible for the “St. Valentine’s Day Massacre” that eliminated his remaining rivals and consolidated his control as a merchant of vice.
Local legend has it that 2121 North Clark Street was utilized to serve as the lookout to plot the crime that took place across the street. Now the home of the Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Company, its relationship interests with Chicagoans have been “strictly honorable” and while that relationship has evolved over the past 53 years, their recipes have never needed to.
Perhaps most famous for their “Pizza Pot Pie”, this cheesy masterpiece elicits groans of satisfaction with each bite. Inspired by deep dish pizza, the sauce is cooked for a staggering 9 hours, the Sicilian dough is triple-raised, and the Wisconsin brick cheese is made specifically for this restaurant. The enjoyment of this dish is further accentuated by its presentation when being removed from its pan by your server once it arrives at your table.
If you share the half-pounder pot pie you should have room left to also share a grinder (which features the same cheese and the vegetarian version of their amazing sauce).
Cash is the only form of payment that is accepted (Al would have ❤️ that), the dining room is slightly darkened for ambiance with period music playing (also for Al?), and reservations are recommended unless you can arrive near opening (or have connections to Al 😳 ).
And that’s…Henry’s Take.
Recommendation credit @ct_miller19
Editor’s Note: A special thanks to our server Caroline for not only excellent service, but also for the helpful background information. 🙌
Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Company
2121 North Clark Street
Chicago, Illinois
(773) 248-2570
